All case studies
Zurich North America

Insurance

Zurich: decide every submission

Move commercial submissions from scattered documents to a cited file and the underwriter’s recorded decision.

By OneShot · Updated

saved per submission in Zurich’s pilot
60 minestimated, 16 underwriters on a vendor’s tool in four offices
saved per submission, vendor’s later study
2 hoursreported by underwriters, above the pilot’s one-hour estimate
underwriters drafting with the tool daily
200+vendor-reported across 30 offices, up from 16 in the pilot

About Zurich North America

Zurich North America’s U.S. Middle Market unit writes commercial accounts by industry practice.

year the Middle Market unit began
2020
of double-digit growth in a row
4 years
    • Application
    • Loss runs
    • Statement of values
    • Fleet schedule
    • Supplemental forms

    Hundreds of pages behind one narrative

    Zurich’s underwriters say an AI drafting tool helped them flag inconsistencies across hundreds of pages per submission.

  • 80%of pilot submissions processed with it

    Every account still needs a written narrative

    After the reading, the underwriter writes the narrative; Zurich’s pilot put a drafting tool on most submissions.

  • 2xunderwriter hires against a year earlier

    Hiring doubles while every file stays long

    The unit hired twice as many underwriters in early 2025, and each faces hundreds of pages per submission.

What Zurich North America has published 4 sources

The published Zurich North America case study describes middle-market underwriters reviewing extensive exposures, loss runs and supplemental forms before writing underwriting narratives. The repeated document work consumed time needed for risk judgment and broker relationships.

Zurich adopted AI-assisted drafting tailored to its risk appetite and preferred format. The OneShot workflow below combines document analysis, broker follow-up and review records in the agent’s tool basket to carry a submission through to the underwriter’s decision.

The cited case study reports that Zurich underwriters saved an average of two hours per submission.

The OneShot solution

Bring each commercial submission to an underwriter’s recorded decision on a complete, cited file.

Starts on

A new broker submission or a material document revision.

  1. Goal

    Submission intake

    Starts on
    A broker email with documents reaches the submission inbox.
    Does
    Logs the submission, clears it against in-force and in-process accounts, and confirms what the insured does.
    Returns
    A cleared submission routed to its practice, or a clearance conflict.
    • Email Inbox
    • Submission records
    • Company Find
    • Company Profile
    • Deep Research
    • Web Search
    2 steps
    1. Log and clear the submission

      Read the broker’s email and attachments from the submission inbox and match the insured against in-force and in-process accounts. A clearance conflict goes to the underwriter before any further work.

    2. Profile the insured

      Check the operations described on the application against the insured’s own website, public record and recent news. Route the submission to the industry practice and regional underwriter its operations belong to.

  2. Goal

    Underwriting file

    Starts on
    Clearance passes, or the broker sends a revised document.
    Does
    Reads every document into page-cited lines, checks locations and fleet, drafts the narrative against appetite.
    Returns
    A cited file of checklist, narrative, contradictions and appetite flags.
    • Document extraction
    • Submission records
    • Flood Zone
    • Disaster Declarations
    • Building Permits
    • Vehicle Identification
    2 steps
    1. Read the documents into a cited file

      Read every document into page-cited lines with the document-extraction tool, check each location’s flood zone, disasters and permits, and decode the VINs. Costed at 200 pages, eight locations and 24 vehicles.

    2. Check appetite and draft the narrative

      Compare exposures, limits and loss history with the practice’s appetite guide and draft the narrative in the underwriter’s format, citing pages. Contradictions are listed as open questions, not resolved.

  3. Goal

    Broker follow-up and decision

    Starts on
    The file has a missing item, or the full draft is ready.
    Does
    Asks the broker for what is missing, folds the answers in, and hands the underwriter the file.
    Returns
    The underwriter’s recorded disposition, with its conditions and referrals.
    • Email
    • Email Inbox
    • Submission records
    2 steps
    1. Chase the broker for missing items

      Email the broker for the missing or conflicting items, such as a loss run year or a location value, with a secure upload link. Read replies back into the file and re-run affected checks.

    2. Record the underwriter’s disposition

      Put the finished file on the underwriter’s request page and record the decision to quote, decline or refer, with conditions. Appetite exceptions go to the designated reviewer; the disposition is written to the submission system.

What the workflow produces

Underwriting review file
  • Submission checklist
  • Risk narrative
  • Open questions
  • Reviewer record
Pays back
Underwriter time returned to risk judgmentAbout 60 minutes per submission
Decided by
Assigned underwriter
Done when
The underwriter has reviewed the current file and recorded a disposition, including any outstanding conditions.

Illustrative

One submission, start to finish

A retail broker sends new business for a midsize Ohio food manufacturer: three plants, eight locations and a 24-unit delivery fleet.

  1. Outside party

    The broker sends 212 pages: application, loss runs, values, fleet schedule, recall supplemental.

  2. Agent

    Clearance finds no existing account, and the file routes to the manufacturing practice underwriter.

  3. Agent

    Finds four years of loss runs, not five, and location 6 $3.1M lower on the application.

  4. Agent

    Emails the broker a secure upload link for the missing loss run and location 6’s value.

  5. Agent

    Outside records put location 6 in a high-risk flood zone; the recall limit exceeds appetite.

  6. Outside party

    The broker uploads the missing loss run: an open contamination claim reserved at $410,000.

  7. Decision

    On the request page, the underwriter quotes with a flood sublimit and refers the recall limit.

Underwriting review file: food manufacturer, Ohio
Broker
Regional retail broker
Received
Mon 08:14, 212 pages
Practice
Manufacturing
Disposition
Quote; recall referred
ItemFindingSourceStatus
ClearanceNo existing account; name matches registryState registry recordCleared
Loss historyFive years, open claim at $410,000Loss runs p. 41 to 58Flagged
Property values$48.6M over 8 locations; location 6 correctedStatement of values, row 6Resolved
FloodLocation 6 in high-risk flood zonePublic flood map lookupSublimit set
Fleet24 units; VINs decode as scheduledFleet schedule p. 112Matches
Product recallRequested limit above practice appetiteSupplemental p. 130Referred

Where it gets hard

  • The agent drafts, never decides

    The workflow does not quote, price, decline or bind. Appetite exceptions go to the designated reviewer with the file.

  • A misread loss run fails visibly

    Scanned loss runs split across pages break extraction. If claims miss the prior carrier’s totals, the line shows unverified.

  • It needs the insurer’s own records

    Clearance needs the in-force book and broker of record; the appetite check needs each practice’s guide and authority levels.

What to measure

  • Submission completeness
  • Broker response time
  • Underwriter rework
  • Time to reviewed disposition

What comes next

  • Start renewals from last year’s narrative, showing only what changed.
  • Track missing items and response time by broker.
  • Package authority referrals for the designated reviewer, file attached.

The agent’s tools

  • Email Inbox
  • Company Find
  • Company Profile
  • Deep Research
  • Web Search
  • Document Extraction goal
  • Flood Zone
  • Disaster Declarations
  • Building Permits
  • Vehicle Identification
  • Email
  • Submission records
  • Document extraction

Live toolConnection to your systems

What each connection does
Submission records
Connect broker submissions, document versions, appetite rules and underwriter review.
Document extraction
Classify incoming documents and read invoices, statements, agreements and customs forms into structured lines, each tied to its source page.

Workflow pricing

Document extraction for the illustrated 200 pages: $10.00 at $0.05 a page. Orchestration, cross-checks, outreach and human review are additional.

Scope the full workflow around your volume, business systems and required outcome.

Discuss workflow pricing →

Bring a workflow
like this one.